Off the top of my head – my three favorite places to go to for a yummy ice cream cone in NYC are:
Sundaes & Cones on 10th Street (and that’s not just because I’m an East Village girl);
Big Gay Ice Cream (when I want a really indulgent fancy soft served cone, like one with pretzels and chocolate syrup or one inspired by key lime pie);
and last but not least….Morgenstern’s Finest Ice Cream on West Houston or Rivington is where I would probably recommend to anybody who needs a good date spot….just don’t over think which ice cream you choose from all the many options and remember that toppings are really cheap! Like an awesome 50Cent per topping, which is why it totally makes my list.